Butter output board
A higher letter means a higher published cash-per-squish number. It ignores wax time and the Buy quote. Peanut is a low letter with a better quote than Blueberry. Muffin and Dubai share 10,000 per squish. Butters with no Index number are left off the board.
Income pet board
Hamster, Guinea Pig, and Capybara are ranked only as income pets. Chicken, Frog, Bunny, Owl, Cow, and Koala do other jobs and are not given an income letter.
S tier
Player decision Use it as the top published Index number. Confirm the Buy quote in game before you save for the announced price.
A tier
Player decision Highest published Mythic Index number in the 30-name list. The wax examples ran about 35 to 53 minutes.
Player decision Buy it when the lever names it. Use Royal only if you accept the other 75%.
Player decision The Royal opening is 625 million, so a named Buy is safer when Icecream is already on screen.
Player decision Best published Legendary output, with chili and flame effects. One wax example was about 31 minutes.
B tier
Player decision Buy ordinary Cookie when you need the type. Use Golden Touch only if you specifically want the Golden form.
Player decision A direct Buy is the reliable path. Twelve percent is a poor plan if you need this one butter.
Player decision Check Daily Rewards before you pay. The panel might say Cake Pop instead.
Player decision Reasonable Gourmet target because the listed chance is half, and the crate fee is 6.25 million.
C tier
Player decision Skip the extra cost if Muffin is available at 2 million for the same 10,000 per squish.
Player decision Best published cash-per-squish per quote among the matched pairs. One Finish Wax example was 20 Robux on Plus.
Player decision Buy it for the sound or the type. Muffin pays more per squish if income is the only goal.
Player decision A step below Popcorn on the Index. Do not confuse it with the Macaron Cafe base skin.
Player decision Different item from Cake Pop. Wax it if you need the Index type. Selling before the pour can miss the discovery.
Player decision Trust the Index for output and the crate preview only as the crate's own label.
D tier
Player decision First Epic on the output list. Still far below Grape.
Player decision Claim it if Day 5 names it. Several copies can sit on one plate.
Player decision Fine as a type. It is not an income target once Epics are affordable.
Player decision Keep the in-game spelling when you search the Index.
Player decision A normal Rare step. It does not out-earn later Epics.
Player decision Better output than Blueberry for less cash. Buy it when the lever offers it and stations are free.
Player decision Do not buy it over Peanut for income. Open Snack only if you need the type and the fee is the one on screen.
Player decision A starter keep, not a Rare. Wax shows a brown pour.
Player decision Early filler. One wax example was about 15 seconds.
Player decision Use it to learn the pour. Replace it once any higher Index butter is waxed.
![[β³ 2H] π§ Stack A Butter Squishy [ASMR] butter-output tier list](/media/optimized/410b274813867cc430476af1-768.webp)